Kancil From Mischief To Moral Education [PDF]

Citation preview

!"#$%&'()*+,(-%.$/%01(2+(-+*"&(345$"2%+# 652/+*7.8'(!"2/%0(9"*:0#20* ;+5*$0'((?+&@(AB>(C+@(D(76:*@>(BEED8>(::@(BBBFBDG H5I&%./04(IJ'(Western States Folklore Society ;2"I&0(KLM'(http://www.jstor.org/stable/1499360 . 6$$0..04'(DNOPQODPBR(PP'RE Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp



. JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].



.



Western States Folklore Society is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Western Folklore.



http://www.jstor.org



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



2+( !"#$%&'()*+,(-%.$/%01( -+*"&(345$"2%+#( !67893(



:6;( ?!"#$%&(%#(9#4+#0.%"#@(%.("(.,"&&A(*"*0(1+*0.2("#B( %,"&(1+5#4(%#(C"D"A(E+*#0+A(F5,"2*"("#4(2/0(-"&"G(.(0OJ&%$%2(.2"204(N+"&(+1(J*0.0#2B( %#N("#("JJ*+J*%"20(*+&0(,+40&(%#($/%&4*0#>.(045$"2%+#H(9#(2/%.(J"J0*A( 9(M%&&($+,J"*0(+*"&(D0*.%+#.(+1(!"#$%&(.2+*%0.(M%2/(,+40*#A(M*%220#( /+M(2/0(%,"N0.(M0(/5,"#.(J*+P0$2(+#2+( +#0.A(%#(+*40*(2+(%&&5.2*"20( "#%,"&.(/"D0(,+*0(2+(4+(M%2/(,002%#N(+5*(+M#(#004.(2/"#(M%2/(2/0( +1(2/0("#%,"&(%2.0&1A( "#4(/+M(2/+.0(J*+P0$2%+#.($/"#N0( #"25*"&(/%.2+*G( ".("(.+$%02G>.( J0*$0%D04(#004.($/"#N0H( 783( -QRF3( S33;(



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



VVV(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



X3F73;=( )QW!WQ;3(



VV[(



,+5.0(400*(%.("( J*%,%2%D0( *5,%#"#2A(,0"#%#N(%2($/0M.(%2.($54A("#4( +#(&0"D0.A(N*"..("#4(1*5%2H( .5I.%.2.(,+.2&G( 6(40.$*%J2%+#(+1(2/0(&%22&0(,+5.0(400*A("#4(2/0(%,J*0..%+#(%2($*0B( "20.A($"#(%#(#+(M"G($"J25*0(2/0(%,J+*2"#$0(+1(2/%.("#%,"&(%#(2/0(-"&"G( "#4(%2($+,0.(".("( .5*J*%.0A(2/0*01+*0A( "#4(C"D"#0.0(+*"&(2*"4%2%+#.A( 2/"2(!"#$%&(%.("( J+M0*15&A("#4(#+2(0#2%*0&G("4+*"I&0A(1%N5*0(%#(2/0( 1+&K&+*0(+1(2/0(*0N%+#H( !6=:9W( F7Q;93F(



!"#$%&(.2+*%0.("I+5#4(%#(-"&"G.%"A(C"D"("#4(E+*#0+H[(!"#$%&(%#B( .+$%02B( .2"#2%"20.( D"&50.(+1(2*"4%2%+#"&( ,"#G(+1(2/0(,+.2(/%N/&GBJ*%]04( %0.(+1(2/0(*0N%+#H(80*0(%.("#(0O",J&0'T( 7/0(,+5.0B400*( /"4(*5#("M"G(M/0#(/0(*0"&%]04(2/0(2%N0*(M".("JB( 6.(/0(*"#(%#(2/0(4"*K(/0(10&&( %#2+( "(400J(J%2(1*+,( M/%$/( /0( J*+"$/%#NH( M".(J"..%#N( "#4(/0(&++K04( 4+M#( $+5&4(#+2(N02(+52H(6#(0&0J/"#2( "2(/%,H( 2/0(,+5.0B400*( %.(1"&&%#N( 4+M#H( ^2/0( ^80G^(./+5204( _5%$KA( .KG( P5,J(%#( %#H( /0*0H^(F+(2/0(0&0J/"#2( 6 120*( "(&%22&0( M/%&0( "(M%&4( $ +M( $",0( P5,J04( "#4(&++K04( %.(1"&&%#N( 4+M#( "2(2/0,H( 4+M#( 2/0(.KG( /0*0A( ^_5%$K`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a[@H( 2/0G( F0D0*"&(+1(!"#$%&>.($/"*"$20*%.2%$.( .2"#4(+52(".(J"*2%$5&"*&G( ."&%0#2(%#( 2/%.(.2+*GH(7/0( "#%,"&(5.0.(/%.(M%2.(2+(N02(+52(+1("(1%O(2/"2(2/0(J*04B( "2+*G(#"25*0(+1(2/0(2%N0*(/".( J52(/%,(%#2+A(I52(/0(4+0.(.+("2(2/0( 0OJ0#.0(+1(+2/0*("#%,"&.H(9#4004A( /0(&%0.(*0"4%&G(M/0#(%2(,002.(/%.( +M#(#004.A("#4("&.+(J*+D+K0.(2/0(+2/0*("#%,"&.(IG(J%#$/%#N(2/0,(%#( [H(9#20*0.2%#N&GA( "&2/+5N/(,+5.0(400*("*0("&.+(1+5#4(%#(F5,"2*"A(9(/"D0(.+(1"*(#+2(1+5#4("#G( "#("$$%40#2(450(2+(%#$+,J&020(4"2"( !"#$%&(.2+*%0.(1*+,(F5,"2*"H(6&2/+5N/(2/%.(%.(J*+I"I&G(.%,J&G( +#0(%#2*%N5%#N( "&20*#"2%D0( $+&&0$2%+#A( 0OJ&"#"2%+#(1+*(2/%.(%.(2/"2(F5,"2*"(%.(2/0(+#&G(+1(2/0.0("*0".( M/0*0(*"II%2.($+0O%.2(M%2/(,+5.0(400*H( TH(7/%.(.2+*G( +1(.+5*$0.A(&%.204(%#(2/0(I%I&%B( "#4(2/0(+#0.(2/"2(1+&&+M("*0(4*"M#(1*+,("(D"*%02G( +N*"J/GH(7/0(#",0(+1(2/0($+&&0$2%+#($"#(I0(1+5#4(%#(J"*0#2/0.0.("2(2/0(0#4(+1(0"$/H(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-( -9F:893)( 7Q( -Q;6W( 3SR:679Q=(



VVT(



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b+5(/"D0(I*+K0#( 2/0( D"N%#"H( I%*2/( M0*0(2/0(M*+#N( &0"D0.H^(7/0(2%N0*( 4%04H( J"#2"#N(?2"I++@A(2/0G( ?8+M0&&(VZa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c^( "#4( / %.( 1 ++2( .25$K( 2+( % 2H( 8 0(2*%04( 2+( %2( I52( / 0( %2A( J+K04( P5.2(N+2( J5./( "M"GA( ,+*0("#4(,+*0(.25$KH( 80(M".(2*"JJ04`( 7/0(#0O2( 2/0(1"*,0*( $",0("#4(J52(2/0(!"#$%&( %#2+( "($"N0H( ,+*#%#NA( 2/0( 1 "*,0*>.( $",0( 2 +( 2"5#2( 2/0( I52( 2 /0( ! "#$%&( 2++K( W"20*A( !"#$%&A( 4+N( 2/0(+110#.%D0H( /0(."%4H(^8"D0(G+5(#+2%$04( "&&(2/0(N+%#N.( ^80GA(45,,G^( +#("*+5#4(2/%.( /+5.0(&"20&Gc^( ^=+A^(2/0(4+N(."%4H(^=+c(8+M($+5&4(G+5(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



VVd(



X3F73;=( )QW!WQ;3(



#+2(#+2%$0c( e*0"2(J*0J"*"2%+#.( "*0(I0%#N(,"40(1+*("(N*"#4(10".2A( I0B( 9(",(2+(I0(,"**%04( $"5.0(2+,+**+M( 2+(2/0(1"*,0*>.( 80>.( 4"5N/20*H( I01+*0(2/0($0*0,+#GH( K00J%#N(,0(%#(2/%.(.J0$%"&(/+5.0(2+(,04%2"20( S+#>2(G+5(M%./( $+5&4( M%2/( 2/0( 1 "*,0*>.( 7/0*0(M%&&( G+5( ,"**G( 4"5N/20*c( "#4(10.2%D%2%0.H^( M%2/( I0(N*0"2( 2/0( ^b0.A(9(M%./(9($+5&4(,"**G( 10".2%#N( ."%4(2/0(4+NA(0#D%+5.&GH( "&&(G+5(/"D0(2+(4+(%.( 1"*,0*>.( ^X0&&A( 4"5N/20*^( 2*"40(J&"$0.(M%2/(,0^(."%4(2/0(!"#$%&(/0&J15&&GH( ^X/0#(2/0(1"*,0*( / %.( /0*0( /0>&&( 2+( %#.20"4( +1(,0H^( 2 +,+**+MA( $+,0.( ,"**G( G+5( 4"5N/20*( 2/0(4+N(+J0#.(2/0($"N0("#4(N02.(%#.%40A( "#4(2/0(!"#$%&( F+A(+1($+5*.0A( 0.$"J0.Hd( !"#$%&(%.("&M"G.("#( %#4%D%45"&A("#4( "&M"G.(%#4%D%45"204H(7/"2( %.A( .2+*%0.(#0D0*($+#2"%#(,+*0(2/"#(+#0(,+5.0(400*A("#4(%#(2/0(.2+*%0.( 1+*( M/%$/(9(M".("I&0(2+(+I2"%#(D0*.%+#.(%#(9#4+#0.%"#A(/0(%.(%#2*+45$04(".( ^!"#$%&^(*"2/0*(2/"#(".( ^"( K"#$%&(?.00K+*( K"#$%&@H^(6&2/+5N/(!"#$%&( .+,02%,0.(20",.(5J( M%2/(+2/0*("#%,"&.A(/0(*0,"%#.("2(/0"*2(.0&1B( "#4(*0"4%&G("I"#4+#.("#4(0D0#(I02*"G.("..+$%"20.(M/0#(%2( %#20*0.204A( %.("4D"#2"N0+5.(2+(4+(.+'( 2/0(2%#G( ,+5.0B400*( Q#$0(5J+#("(2%,0( "#4(2/0(M"20*B2+*2+%.0( M0#2( +52( 2+(1%#4( 1*5%2H( &"40#(M%2/( "(2*00( $&+.0(IG( 7/0G(1+5#4( 2+N02/0*( *%J0(1*5%2( "(/+5.0H(^9($"#>2($&%,I( ."%4(2/0(,+5.0B400*A( ^I52(9>&&(N%D0( 2*00^( 5J(2/"2( I*"#$/H^( F+(/0(J5./04( G+5("(&0N(5JA("#4(2/0#( G+5($"#(N02(+#(2+(2/"2( 5J( 2/0(2+*2+%.0( +#2+(2/0(&+M0*,+.2( I*"#$/H( 7+*2+%.0( 4+M#("&&(2/0( 2/*0M( I52(2/0#( 4%4#>2( K#+M( /+M(2+(N02(4+M#A( "#4($"&&04(2+(-+5.0B400*( 1*5%2A( 1+*(/0&JH(^Q/`(e02(4+M#("#GM"G( ."%4(-+5.0B400*H( ^E52(9( G+5(&%K0A^( $"#>2( "#4(9($"#>2( I"$KM"*4.H^( ^7/0#(2/*+M( N02(4+M#(1+*M"*4.( N02(4+M#( 4+M#^( "#4(7+*2+%.0( ."%4(-+5.0B400*A( 2/*0M( /%,.0&1( 4+M#("#4( G+5*.0&1( $",0(2+(2/0(N*+5#4( "(N*0"2( M%2/( 2/54H( 7/0(J0+J&0(%#(2/0(/+5.0(/0"*4( 2/0(.+5#4("#4(."%4(^7/0*0>.("(45*%"#(1"&&%#NH^( +1($+5*.0( ?-+5.0B400*( M/%&0( 2/0(1*5%2A( 2/0(2+*2+%.0( %.($"J25*04A( "#4(&012( 2+(/%.(+M#( 0.$"J0.(M%2/( 40D%$0.@( ?8+.0("#4(-$S+5N"&&(VZff@H( 92(,5.2(I0(J+%#204(+52(2/"2(!"#$%&(%.("(I0&+D04($/"*"$20*(%#(2*"4%B( 2%+#"&(1+&K&+*0H( 6.(J+%#204(+52(%#(e00*2](?VZf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dH(:+&&0$204("#4(2*"#.&"204(IG(,G.0&1( %#(-"&"#NA(3".2(C"D"A(45*%#N(2/0(.5,,0*(+1(VZaZH(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-( -9F:893)( 7Q( -Q;6W( 3SR:679Q=(



VVY(



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c( 1&520H( 1&520A( 2+(I&+M(2/0(1&520( "#4(-+5.0B400*( 1+*0D0*H^( F+(7%N0*(M"#204( /0"&2/G( 2+&4(/%,(/0>4(./+M(/%,(/+M(2+(4+(%2H(80(."%4(7%N0*(./+5&4(J52(/%.( 2/0( I",I++(2*00.A( M/%$/( I02M00#( 2/0(2M+( 7%N0*(4%4A("#4(M/0#( 2+#N50( M%#4( I&0M( /%.(2+#N50( "#4(-+5.0B400*( 1*00( ?e00*2]( N+2("M"G( N+2($"5N/2( VZfU@H( 3J%.+40.(.5$/(".(2/0(J*0$04%#N($"#(I0(&%#K04(%#("( #0D0*B0#4%#N( M%2/(^6#+2/0*(2%,0A(HHH( H^(7/0(.2+B( &%#K04(2+N02/0*( .0*%0.(+1(D%N#0220.A( *%0.("*0("&M"G.("I+52(!"#$%&A("#4(!"#$%&(#0D0*("JJ0"*.(%#("#(%#$%40#B( 2"&(*+&0H()+*(0O",J&0A("&2/+5N/(,+5.0(400*(M0*0(/5#204("#4(0"20#(IG( .+,0(N*+5J.(%#(2/0("*0"A(2/0*0(%.(#0D0*(,0#2%+#(+1(!"#$%&(".(J"*2(+1( "( ,0"&A(+*(".( "#( "#%,"&(%#$%40#2"&&G(0#$+5#20*04(M/%&0(2*"D0&%#N( 2/*+5N/(2/0(P5#N&0H( 7/0( #0O2(.2+*G( ./+M.(!"#$%&(2/0(1&"220*0*A( I+2/("#(".2520(P54N0( +1( $/"*"$20*(%#(5#$+D0*%#N(+2/0*($*0"25*0.>(M0"K#0..A(".(M0&&(".(2/0("*$/( ,"#%J5&"2+*(%#(0OJ&+%2%#N(2/+.0(M0"K#0..0.(1+*(/%.(+M#(J5*J+.0.'( 6(,+5.0B400*( M".(M"&K%#N( 80($+5&4(.00( "&+#N(2/0(I"#K(+1("(*%D0*H( .0D0*"&($*+$+4%&0.( ^80G( &G%#N(%#(2/0(,54("2(2/0(.%40(+1(2/0(*%D0*H( 1*%0#4.`^( /0($"&&04(+52H(^b+5("*0(*0"&&G( b+5($+5&4( D0*G( I%N("#4(.2*+#N`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c^(7/0( 4%4(".(2/0G( $*+$+4%&0.( M0*0(2+&4H(7/0G(1+*,04( "(&%#0(1*+,( +#0(.%40(+1( 2/0(*%D0*( 2+(2/0(+2/0*H( 7/0(,+5.0B400*( +#(2/0( P5,J04(4+M#(&%N/2&G( I"$K(+1(2/0(#0"*0.2($*+$+4%&0H( ^Q#0A(2M+A(2/*00^(/0($+5#204(".(/0( M"&K04( "$*+..( 2/0(*%D0*( +#(2/0%*( X/0#( /0(*0"$/04( 2/0(+2/0*( I"$K.H( .%40A( /0(P5,J04(L5%$K&G( +#2+(2/0(I"#KH(^7/"#K(G+5(D0*G( ,5$/A( N0#2&0,0#^(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



X3F73;=( )QW!WQ;3(



VVf(



7/0( 2/0(*%D0*H^( 1002( M02( 2+(N02(,G( M"#2( /0($"&&04(+52H(^9(4%4#>2( $*+..%#N( ./+5204H( ,+5.0B400*^( $*+$+4%&0.( *+"*04(%#("#N0*H(^S+#>2(1+*N02A( 2/0G( $"2$/( Q#0(4"G(M0(./"&&( ".(%#(2/0(M"20*H( ^M0($"#(&%D0(+#(&"#4(".(M0&&( G+5( "#4(20"$/(G+5("( N++4(&0..+#H^(^8"(/"(/"^(&"5N/04(2/0(,+5.0B400*( ?:+,I0*(VZad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a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



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-( -9F:893)( 7Q( -Q;6W( 3SR:679Q=(



VV\(



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a[@H( 4%.J+."&^( %.("&.+(!"#$%&(2/0(I*"NN"*2A( !"#$%&(2/0(1&"220*0*( "#4(/%.("**+N"#$0(%.( %#(2/0(1+&&+M%#N( %&&5.2*"204( .2+*G'( "*+5#4(M0"*%#N( "(.#"K0(".("(I0&2A( -+5.0B400*( M".(.2*522%#N( I*"NN%#N( /0("&+#0($+5&4(M0"*( %2H(80($"&&04(+52(2+(2/0( I0$"5.0( +2/0*( "#%,"&.( ^80GA( 45,,%0.`( S+#>2(G+5(M%./( .#"K0(".("(I0&2c( E52(G+5( G+5($+5&4(M0"*(2/%.( $"#>2A( +#&G(9($"#H^f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fH(:+&&0$204(IG(,G.0&1( %#(-"&"#NA(.5,,0*(VZaZH(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



VVa(



X3F73;=( )QW!WQ;3(



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a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



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-( -9F:893)( 7Q( -Q;6W( 3SR:679Q=(



VVZ(



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c( 783( .(,+*"&(045$"2%+#c(7/0*0( 2%$5&"*&G( !"#$%&(%.(.%,J&G( "(D0*G( "*0(.0D0*"&(*0".+#.H()%*.2&GA( %#( %,J+*2"#2( 1%N5*0( 2*"4%2%+#"&(1+&K&+*0A("#4(%2(%.(#"25*"&(2/"2(/0(M+5&4($+#2%#50(2+(I0( 2/"2(#"5N/2G( $/"*B( F0$+#4&GA(2/0*0(%.(2/0(#"25*"&("22*"$2%+#( %,J+*2"#2H( "$20*.(.00,(5#%D0*."&&G( 2+(/"D0(1+*($/%&4*0#(?"#4(1+*("45&2.(".(M0&&`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g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



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-( -9F:893)( 7Q( -Q;6W( 3SR:679Q=(



V[V(



4+]0#.($+5&4(I0(2+&4(%#("#(0D0#%#NH(7/0G("*0(&++.0&G(&%#K04(2+N02/0*(



M%2/("#( %#1+*,"&($+##0$2+*( .5$/( ".( ^6#+2/0*( 2%,0( HH( H^(9#( $+#2*".2A(



2/0(&"20*(.2+*%0.(1+&&+M("( $+#D0#2%+#"&A(X0.20*#B.2G&0( J&+2(.2*5$25*0A( +1("( %#2*+45$2%+#( M%2/("(.$0#0B.022%#N( J*+I&0,A("#4(!"#B( I0N%##%#NA( "#4( $%&>.(*0.+&52%+#(+1(2/0(J*+I&0,H(Q#0(.2+*GA( 2/+5N/A(%.(2*"#.%2%+#"&A( %2( %2( %.(%#20*0.2%#N( %2.(J&+2(.2*5$25*0( I0$"5.0A(.2*"#N0(2/+5N/( %.A( J"D0.( 2/0(M"G(1+*(2/0(0#2*G(+1(!"#$%&(%#2+(,+40*#(M*%220#( &%20*"25*0'a( !"#$%&( 7/0(:&0D0*(



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a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a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



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



V[[(



X3F73;=( )QW!WQ;3(



2/"2(%.(#+2(^J*"%.0M+*2/GH^( 7/0("52/+*(+1(!"#B( "D+%4(."G%#N("#G2/%#N( /".(M*%220#( +2/0*( I 52( #+#0(+1(2/0(+2/0*( :0*4%K( I++K.A( $%&(b"#N( ,"#G( $+#2"%#.(.5$/("(M"*#%#NA(.5NN0.2%#N(2/"2(2/0("52/+*(%.( %#2*+45$2%+#.( "M"*0(+1(2/0(J*0$"*%+5.#0..(+1(I*%#N%#N(!"#$%&(%#2+(2/0(4+,"%#(+1( &%20*"25*0(2"*N0204(.J0$%1%$"&&G( "2($/%&4*0#H(7/%.( .2+*G(*0J*0.0#2.("( $"52%+5.("220,J2(2+(2"K0("4D"#2"N0(+1(2/0(%,J+*2"#$0("#4("JJ0"&( +1( !"#$%&(1+*(045$"2%+#"&(J5*J+.0.A(M/%&0(*%44%#N(2/0(.2+*%0.(+1(.+,0(+1( 7/0(.2+*%0.(J5I&%./04("120*(!"#$%&(G"#N($0*4%K( 2/0(&0..(."D+*G(%#$%40#2.H( /"D0("($+#D0#2%+#"&( $/%&4*0#>.(.2+*G( I++K(.2+*G( .$0#0(%.( .2*5$25*0BB2/0( 2 /0( %.( " #4(2/0(!"#$%&(*0.+&D0.( 2 /0( .02A( J*+I&0,( %#2*+45$04A( J*+I&0,H( 7/0(,+.2(%,J+*2"#2( .2*5$25*"&( $/"#N0(%.(%#(2/0(*+&0(+1(2/0(#"**"2+*A( "#4( M/"2(2/0(#"**"2+*(,5.2(0OJ&%$%2&G(.2"20A(*"2/0*(2/"#(2"K0(1+*( N*"#204H(7/0( .2+*%0.(,5.2(#+M($+#2"%#(0OJ&%$%2(.2"20,0#2.(+1(/+M( ^I"4^(2/0(2%N0*(+*(+2/0*(&"*N0A(40.2*5$2%D0( "#%,"&.("*0A("#4(/+M(!"#B( $%&>.(2*%$K.( "*0(.%,J&G(%#(*0.J+#.0(2+(.+,0(J*+D+$"2%+#H(7/0(#"**"2+*( .02.("(#0M($+#20O2(%#(M/%$/(!"#$%&>.(2*"%2.("#4(I0/"D%+*.("*0(%#20*B( +1(,"#G(2*"%2.( J*0204A("#4( J"D0.(2/0(M"G(1+*(2/0(*0%#20*J*02"2%+#( M/%$/(,%N/2( .00,(%#"JJ*+J*%"20(1+*(,+40*#($/%&4*0#>.(045$"2%+#H(9#( +2/0*(M+*4.A(2/0($"*#%D+*0.( ,5.2(I0(J+*2*"G04( ".(0OJ&%$%2&G( ^".K%#N(1+*( %2^(%#(+*40*(2+(P5.2%1G( 2/0(40$0%2(5.04("N"%#.2(2/0,H(!"#$%&>.(.,"&&(.%]0( "#4(*0&"2%D0(J/G.%$"&(M0"K#0..("*0("&.+(0OJ&%$%2&G( .2"204A(.+(2/0(*0"40*( $"#(.00(2/"2(/0(/".(#+($/+%$0(I52(2+(*0.+*2(2+(2*%$K0*G( %1(/0(M%./0.(2+( .5*D%D0H(7/%.(%.($&0"*(%#(2/0(#0O2(.2+*GA( %#(M/%$/(2/0(!"#$%&(J5#%./0.("( $*+$+4%&0(1+*(%2.(&"$K(+1(N*"2%2540'( 7/0( )"I&0( :*+$+4%&0( "#4(2/0( +1(2/0( E511"&+( /+2(4"GH(:*+$+4%&0( 92>.("(*0"&&G( 2"K0.( ./0&20*( 5#40*("(./"4G( 2*00H(:*+$B( +4%&0(1"&&.( M%2/( 0O/"5.2%+#H( "( ".&00J(I0$"5.0(/0(%.(+D0*2"K0#( F5440#&G( M%#4( $+,0.( 2*00( 1"&&.( 4+M#H( 7/0($*+$+4%&0>.( 5JH(7/0(./"4G( .2*+#N( I+4G( %.(J%##04( 4+M#( 7/0($*+$+4%&0( ,+"#.( %#(J"%#H(7/0($*+$+4%&0( IG(2/0(2*00H( $*%0.H( 7/0($*+$+4%&0( 2*%0.( 2+($"&&(1+*( "(M"20*( I511"&+( /0&JH(W5$K%&GA( J"..0.( ".K.(2/0(I511"&+( 1+*(/0&JH(7/0(I511"&+( 100&.(.+**G( IGH(7/0($*+$+4%&0( 7/0(I511"&+( &%12.( 2/0(2*00(1*+,( 2/0(I+4G(+1(2/0( .00%#N(2/0($*+$+4%&0H( $*+$+4%&0H( 7/0($*+$+4%&0( $"#(I*0"2/0( 7/0(I+4G(+1(2/0($*+$+4%&0( 1*00&GH( 100&.( 4+0.#>2( 9#(1"$2A( 2/0( &%N/2( "N"%#H(7/0($*+$+4%&0( 0OJ*0..( "#G(2/"#K.H( $*+$+4%&0( ".K.(1+*(,+*0(/0&J(1*+,( 2/0(M"20*( I511"&+H( 7/0($*+$+4%&0( 2+(I0($"**%04( M"#2.( 2+(2/0(+2/0*( "$*+..( .%40(+1(2/0(*%D0*H( 7/0(I511"&+( %.( 2+( 2/0( $ *+$+4%&0( 7/0(I511"&+( $"**%0.( 2/0( $ *+$+4%&0H( *0"4G( /0&J( "N"%#H( 7/0(I511"&+( $*+..0.( 2/0(*%D0*H( 2/0(I511"&+( %.(.25##04H( 7/0( F5440#&GA( I511"&+>.( I"$K(%.(I0%#N( I%220#( 7/0(I511"&+( IG(2/0($*+$+4%&0`( .L50"&.(1+*( "(,+5.0B400*( 7/0(,+5.0B400*( $+,0.( M"#2.( 2+(.00( /0&JH(W5$K%&GA( "&+#NH( "(*0B0#"$2,0#2( +1(0D0#2.H( F+A(2/0($*+$+4%&0( N+0.(I"$K(2+(2/0(1%*.2( J&"$0H( 7/0($*+$+4%&0( %.($"**%04( 2+(2/0(1"&&0#( 2*00H( 7/0(1"&&0#( 2*00(%.(J&"$04(+#(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-(-9F:893)(7Q(-Q;6W(3SR:679Q=(



V[T(



"I+52(I0"*B( $+,J&"%#.( I+4G("N"%#H(7/0($*+$+4%&0( 2+J(+1(2/0($*+$+4%&0>.( &02.( 2/0( I0(.L5"./04( I5*40#H( -+5.0B400*( $*+$+4%&0( IG(2/0(1"&&0#( %#N(2/%.( %2H(7/0(I511"&+( %.(#+2( %.("&&+M04(2+(M%2#0..( 2*00H(7/0(M"20*(I511"&+( 2+(2/0($*+$+4%&0H( 7/"2(%.(2/0( "&&+M04(2+(/0&J("N"%#H(-+5.0B400*( J+%#2.( +1(2/0(.$/0,%#N( 4004.H(7/0($*+$+4%&0( M/+(4+0.#>2( *0.5&2( $*+$+4%&0>.( /+M(2+(*025*#( K#+M( "(1"D+*( ?F5*".4%(VZa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�..( %2G(2+(1%N/2( M/%$/(,5.2(I0(2*0.J"..04(5J+#(IG("#+2/0*("#%,"&(I01+*0(!"#$%&(*0B( .+*2.(2+(2*%$K0*G( 2+(4010#4(/%.(J*+J0*2G'( 7/0()"I&0(+1(!"#$%&("#4(3&0J/"#2(



62(2/0(04N0(+1(2/0(1+*0.2( 2/0(,+5.0B400*( &%D0.(J0"$015&&GH( -5$/(1++4( %.(4%."JJ+%#204( I0$"5.0( $"#(I0(1+5#4(2/0*0H(Q#0(4"GA(-+5.0B400*( "*0(I*+K0#( 4+M#H(6#(0&0J/"#2( $+,0.H(e*004%&G( 2/0(0&0B( ,"#G(J&"#2.( I52("( 0"2.(2/0(1+&%"N0H( 7/0(,+5.0B400*( ,"4("2(2/0(0&0J/"#2( J/"#2( N02.( %.#>2( "I&0(2+(1%N/2( M%2/( "#(0&0J/"#2H( 6#(%40"($+,0.(2+(/%,H( ,+5.0B400*( 2+(2*"J(2/0(0&0J/"#2H( -+5.0B400*( M"#2.( 1%#4.( "#(+&4(M0&&H( -+5.0B400*( 7/%.(M0&&(%.(I%N(0#+5N/( 2+(/+&4("#(0&0J/"#2H( -+5.0B400*( N+0.(4+M#(2+( 2/0(I+22+,( +1(2/0( M0&&H( 1+*( 2+(J"..(IGH(X/0#( -+5.0B400*( M"%2.( 3&0J/"#2( 2/"2( 4+M#H( -+5.0B400*( 2/0(.KG( %.(1"&&%#N( ."G.( 3&0J/"#2( J"..0.A( 3&0J/"#2( 4+M#(IG(2/0(.KGH(3&0J/"#2( %.("1*"%4(+1(N022%#N( 2+(2"K0( .2*5$K( M"#2.( %#(2/0(+&4(M0&&H(-+5.0B400*( ./0&20*( ."G.(2/"2(2/0(0&0J/"#2( ,"G($+,0( 4+M#(%#2+(2/0(M0&&H(X/0#(3&0J/"#2(N02.(2+(2/0(I+22+,( +1(2/0(M0&&A( -+5.0B400*( -+5.0B400*( N02.(5J(+#(2/0(I"$K(+1(2/0(0&0J/"#2H( &0"J.(2+( %#(2/0(I+22+,( +1(2/0(M0&&(?F5*".4%( %.(2*"JJ04( 2/0(2+JH(=+M(2/0(0&0J/"#2( VZaf"@H( :+#2*".2(2/%.(.2+*G( M%2/(2/0(,+*0(2*"4%2%+#"&( D0*.%+#H(F+,0/+MA(2/0( 2 /0( 2/"2( ,+40*#(.2+*G( &0"D0.(+#0(M%2/( .0#.0( 2/0(0&0J/"#2(M".(^".K%#N( %#(&0"D%#N(/%,( 1+*(%2A^("#4(2/"2(!"#$%&(/".(./+M#("4,%*"I&0(*0.2*"%#2( %#(2/0(I+22+,(+1(2/0(J%2(2+(*0$+#.%40*(/%.(I0/"D%+*H(9#(2/0(,+40*#(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



V[d(



X3F73;=()QW!WQ;3(



.2+*%0.A(.#0"K%#0..(%.(#+2("52+,"2%$"&&G( P5.2%1%04A(0D0#(1+*(.5*D%D"&H( 2/"2(/"D0(2"K0#(+#( #0N"2%D0($+##+2"2%+#.("*0(.+,0B( :/"*"$20*%.2%$.( 2+(2/0($"*#%D+*0(*"2/0*(2/"#(2/0(!"#$%&A("#4(2/0(.2+B( 2%,0.("22*%I5204( 1+*(!"#$%&>.(2*%$K.B0%2/0*(2/0( *%0.(,5.2($+#2"%#("#(0OJ&%$%2( P5.2%1%$"2%+#( .#0"K.( I0/%#4(/%,("#4(2*%0.( 2+(0"2(/%,A(+*(2/0(0&0J/"#2( 2%N0*( 5J( /%.( + *( 2/0( $ *+$+4%&0( 0"2.( 2"K0.("4D"#2"N0(+1(I511"&+>.( &0"D0.A( ^N*004%&G^( /0&J15�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`( 7/0(2%N0*( *+"*.H( 7/0(2%N0*( 2+(0"2(2/0(,+5.0B400*`( ,0"#.( 7/0(,+5.0B400*( %.("1*"%4( +1(2/0(2%N0*A( /+M0D0*( /0(L5%$K&G( $+,0.( 2+(/%.( .0#.0.H( -+5.0B400*( 2/0(2%N0*( %.(N&"4A( ."G.(2/"2( ,"G(0"2(/%,H(7/0(2%N0*( I0$"5.0(/0(N02.(2/%.( 40&%$%+5.( 1++4H(E01+*0( -+5.0B400*( %.(0"20#(IG(2/0( -+5.0B400*( M"#2.( 2+(J52(+#("(I0&2H(7/0(2%N0*( 2%N0*A( N02.(,"4H(-+5.0B(



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-( -9F:893)( 7Q( -Q;6W( 3SR:679Q=(



V[Y(



2+(M0"*("(I0&2H( -+5.0B400*( ./+M.( 400*(4+0.(#+2(/"D0(J0*,%..%+#( 7%N0*( +#(2/0(I0&2H(7%N0*(J52.(+#(2/0(I0&2H(92( /%.(I0&2H(7%N0*($"#>2(M"%2(2+(2*G( +52(2/"2( 2/0(I0&2(%.("(.#"K0`( 7/0(J+%.+#+5.( I%20.( 2/0(2%N0*H( 25*#.( .#"K0( %.(1*004( 1*+,( -+5.0B400*( ? F5*".4%( V ZafI@H( 4"#N0*( !"#$%&($/"*"$20*( 7/0(2*"4%2%+#"&( M".($&0"*&G( "45&2A(I52(2/0*0(%.(.+,0( ".(2+(M/+(2/0($/%&4(*0"40*(%.(.5JJ+.04(2+(%40#2%1G( M%2/(%#( ",I%N5%2G( 2/0(,+40*#(.2+*%0.H(62(2%,0.A(!"#$%&(.00,.(2+(I0("#("45&2("52/+*%2G( 2/0($/%&4(%.(.5JJ+.04(2+(+I0GA(I52(+2/0*(2%,0.(/0(.00,.(2+(I0("( 1%N5*0( $/%&4(M%2/(M/+,(2/0($/%&4(%.(.5JJ+.04(2+(%40#2%1GH( 7/5.A("&+#N(M%2/( 2/0(40.0O5"&%]"2%+#(+1(!"#$%&(/".($+,0("($+#$+,%2"#2( P5D0#%&%]"2%+#A( ".(40J%$204(%#(2/0(&".2(.2+*G( +1(2/0(!"#$%&(.0*%0.'( 7/0( )"I&0( "#4(2/0( :"2( +1(2/0( 7%N0*( +1(2/0( "#%,"&H( 80(&%K0.( 2+(0"2( 7%N0*(%.(2/0(K%#N( P5#N&0H(7%N0*(%.("(*52/&0..( +2/0*( "#%,"&.H( -+5.0B400*( 4+0.#>2( &%K0(2/0(2%N0*( I0$"5.0(2/0(2%N0*( &%K0.( 2+(0"2(+2/0*( "#%,"&.H( Q#0(4"GA( -+5.0B400*( 7%N0*(.J%0.(+#(-+5.0B400*H( %.(./+$K04( 2+(.00(2%N0*H( 8%.(&%10( %.(%#(4"#N0*H( -+5.0B400*( 4+0.#>2( &+.0(/%.( M%2.H( 80(2/%#K.( /"*4(/+M(2+(0.$"J0H(7/0(2%N0*( %.(4%."JJ+%#204( I0$"5.0( 2/0(,+5.0B400*( %.(,+*0( 7/0(,+5.0B400*( 2/0(2%N0*H( D%N%&"#2H( "JJ*+"$/0.( -+5.0B400*( .02.("($+#4%2%+#H( 0"2(2/0(,+5.0B400*A( ".(&+#N(".( 7%N0*(,"G( %2(%.(M%2#0..04( $"&&.(2/0($"2H(7/0($"2($+,0.( IG(2/0($"2H(-+5.0B400*( *%N/2( 2+(.00(2/0($"2H(7/0(2%N0*( "#4(2/0($"2(*0.J0$2( 0"$/( "M"GH( 7%N0*(%.(./+$K04( +2/0*H( E0$"5.0(2/0(,+5.0B400*( %.("(1*%0#4( +1(2/0($"2>.A( 2/0#(2/0(2%N0*( 4+0.#>2( M"#2( 2+(0"2(2/0(,+5.0B400*( ?F5*".4%(VZaf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



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



X3F73;=( )QW!WQ;3(



V[f(



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a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



This content downloaded from 130.194.20.173 on Fri, 26 Apr 2013 00:39:55 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions



);Q-( -9F:893)( 7Q( -Q;6W( 3SR:679Q=(



V[\(



,"%#2"%#(/%.(J+M0*("#4( "JJ0"&( M/0#(2/0(,+*0(0O$%2%#N(2*"4%2%+#"&( .2+*%0.("*0(#+(&+#N0*(2+&4c(7/0( ^J"#$".%&"]"2%+#^(+1(!"#$%&($+#2%#50.A( "#4( ,"#G(L50.2%+#.($"#(+#&G(I0("#.M0*04(IG(M"%2%#N("#4(M"2$/%#N( +D0*(2/0(#0O2(10M(G0"*.H( R#%D0*.%2G( +1(Q*0N+#( 35N0#0A(Q*0N+#( ;010*0#$0.(:%204( )+&K(7"&0.(+1(2/0(X+*&4H( =0M(b+*K'(S+5I&04"GH( :+&0A(C+"##"H(VZa[H(E0.2BW+D04( F2+*%0.( E+*#0+H( :+,I0*A(W0+#H( VZadH()"D+*%20( 1*+,( C"K"*2"'(