NSDC Adjudication Sheet [PDF]

Citation preview

NATIONAL SCHOOL DEBATING CHAMPIONSHIP Adjudication Sheet Round



: ___________________________________________



Chairperson Motion



:



: _______________________



Timekeeper



Room : __________________



: _____________________________



______________________________________________________________________ Judge : _________________ (mandatory to fill)



PROPOSITION : _______________________________ Order



Name



STYLE (24 - 32)



CONTENT (24 - 32)



STRATEGY (12 - 16)



Total (60 -80) 83)



Time (normal: 8min.)



(12-16)



(12-16)



(6-8)



(30-40)



(normal: 5 min.)



1st



2nd



3rd (Reply speech is scored as half of substantive speech) Reply



Final Score Opposition



: _____________________________



Order



Name



STYLE (24 - 32)



CONTENT (24 - 32)



STRATEGY (12 - 16)



Total (60 -80)



Time (normal: 8min.)



(12-16)



(12-16)



(6-8)



(30-40)



(normal: 5 min.)



1st 2nd 3rd (Reply speech is scored as half of substantive speech) Reply



Final Score Winner



:



Best Speaker :



Affirmative / Negative



Close / Clear



__________________



Margin



:



_____________________



Marking Scale Some scenarios of Substantive speeches (1st, 2nd, and 3rd) are marked as follows : Judge Point Meaning



Decision



Winning Team



60-61



Very poor



Unanimous



3



Defeated Team 0



62-65



Below average – Poor



Split



2



1



Total Score



66-69



Pass



70



Average



71-73



Slightly Above average, a more solid analysis and structured speech Advanced analysis, outstanding persuasiveness



74-76 76-79



Advanced analysis, outstanding persuasiveness, excellent structure



80



Prophetic



Single Adjudicator



Clear Debate 3



0 Close Debate



2



1